?

Log in

No account? Create an account

Previous Entry | Next Entry

Go to IMDB.
Look up just about any movie, but specifically a more complicated one. (Fight Club, Donnie Darko, hell, even LA Confidential) There you will find people overanalyzing the hell out of every little thing.
Now, usually, I LIKE IT when people think about movies. But not like this. And not these people.
These people are removing ANY JOY from watching movies by doing this to them. "How could it be possible for Jack to be in the Airport and for Tyler to be getting into a car at the same time? how can that be? what's YOUR theory?!" and people actually HAVE theories about this.

They're killing the whole point and purpose and escape and goodness.
They're just so desperate to be the one who saw through it all and knows the secrets (because they have no real talent themselves) that they're more than happy to circle jerk for a long long time over these questions that have nothing to do with the film, the film makers, or what the real MESSAGE of the film is.


guh.

Comments

saintsteven
Feb. 1st, 2003 07:03 pm (UTC)
I dont know if I'd go to IMDB and join a debate, but after watching Fight Club so many times, I can honestly say I've thought about these things.
I came to the conclusion that there are events where Jack is Tyler, and events where Jack imagines what Tyler would do.. the car is a good example, because that comes right after Jack's frustration is building up when he can't get his luggage. He imagines himself (Tyler) stealing a car, but since he's still grounded in reality as Jack, he decides to go the more reasonable route and call for a cab.

Maybe it's seeing what you want to see, and making something out of nothing.. but it's fun. It reminds me of the poetry unit in 8th grade english, when we'd interpret a poem line by line, finding the *true* meaning behind every little metaphor and exhausting every possible explanation when it seemed like reading it, getting the general idea and enjoying it for what it is would've been a better way to get the most out of it. But I'm not a big fan of poetry, and I love Fight Club, so there's some bias there.

And a big run-on sentence back there.
maddening
Feb. 1st, 2003 08:00 pm (UTC)
I dunno... I can see doing it in a fun way. I can see sitting there and thinking... "ooh, well but MAAAAAAAAAYBE... this is how it is, eh? eh?" in a silly way.
But uhm.. they don't do that.

When I was going through a chunk of insomnia induced by extreme heartbreak awhile ago, I literally watched fight club at least twice a day, sometimes more, for a month. And ya know.. it just never occured to me to pick it apart like that.

I also hated and thought it pointless when he did the line by line picking apart of poems when I was in junior high.

And the thing is... I dig both poetry AND the movie...

so I dunno.

Profile

NewYorkNewYork
maddening
A Non-Newtonian Fluid

Latest Month

March 2010
S M T W T F S
 123456
78910111213
14151617181920
21222324252627
28293031   

Page Summary

Powered by LiveJournal.com
Designed by Tiffany Chow